Only Communists would think that it makes sense to actually implement bad science fiction plot ideas.
It was Robert Heinlein, I believe, who wrote that the essence of science fiction is to take some idea or trend and play it out to its logical, if absurd, conclusion. For Heinlein, the essence of science fiction was to ponder the question, "if this goes on..."
Normal people may wonder what would happen "if this goes on," but when they ponder the conclusion, they usually draw back in a human horror of the inhuman implications.
Not so with science fiction authors and Communists.
Only Communists would think that a "one child policy" implemented by forced sterilizations and abortions, inevitably leading to a massive selective abortion of females and thirty five million womenless men who have nothing better to do than revolt against the government that caused their predicament is a good idea. Only Communists would think that it is even possible to create an
alternate society of intergenerational slave labor/political concentration camps.
In the same vein, only Communists would think of this bit of science fiction outlined in
this Wintery Knight post:
Doctors in southern China are working around the clock to fulfil a government goal to sterilise — by force if necessary — almost 10,000 men and women who have violated birth control policies. Family planning authorities are so determined to stop couples from producing more children than the regulations allow that they are detaining the relatives of those who resist. About 1,300 people are being held in cramped conditions in towns across Puning county, in Guangdong Province, as officials try to put pressure on couples who have illegal children to come forward for sterilisation.
And:
In a news conference on Capitol Hill, several speakers, including attorney David Matas of B’nai Brith Canada and Ethan Gutmann of the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, said their investigations have unearthed a grisly trade in which an estimated 9,000 members of Falun Gong have been executed for their corneas, lungs, livers, kidneys and skins.
They likened the practice to the Nazi treatment of Jewish prisoners in World War II concentration camps, which included using them for sadistic medical experiments and taking the gold fillings from the teeth of corpses. The newest wrinkle, they said, is that organs from other religious prisoners — specifically dissidents from China’s Christian, Muslim and Tibetan Buddhist communities — are also being harvested to satisfy an insatiable global demand.
The common thread might be the Communist belief that human beings are just sophisticated animals, and, therefore, there is no ontological barrier against using human beings like animals.
It is said that truth is stranger than fiction because fiction has to be plausible, which seems accurate until some utopian humanist gets involved.